PianoTech Archive

  • 1.  Petrov 125 IV noise problems

    Posted 10-29-2000 05:01
    From J Patrick Draine <draine@mediaone.net>
    
    Dear Petrov experts:
    I have a customer with a new (3 months old) Petrov 125 IV, their 49" 
    upright. I tuned it in June, shortly after delivery. He called 
    yesterday complaining about annoying rattly action noise. My 
    diagnosis based on the phone call was loose hammer flange screws, or 
    even perhaps loose glue joints between the hammer/shank/butt -- but 
    that was incorrect.
    
    I dropped by late in the day with just a few minutes to spare before 
    heading home in time for various family activities.
    The noises are apparent mainly when the damper pedal is engaged and 
    the piano is being played fairly vigorously. While we can isolate a 
    few target source notes they don't generate much noise unless all the 
    rest of the repetitive r&r/Bruce Hornsby/stride piano chording is 
    going on at the same time.
    If it were a grand I'd suspect damper wires vibrating slightly 
    against bass strings -- but it's an upright.
    I *did* tighten the hammer flanges, damper heads, damper flanges of 
    the (suspected) source notes, but they were already firm, and no 
    improvement occurred.
    The pedal dowels were the next suspects: the plastic/metal 
    pins/rubber contacts between the (aluminum not wood) dowels had 
    excess free play  -- BUT installing a better bushing didn't help.
    Is there something potentially funky about the damper lift rod 
    bushings? I didn't have time to pull the action, but still managed to 
    get home late & have the family ticked off at me.
    The customer bought the piano in NYC to save $2K compared to the 
    local dealer; the local dealer won't give him the time of day now, so 
    dropping the problem on the local dealer isn't an option.
    Besides, it *should* be the sort of thing that goes away with a few 
    tightened screws, etc.!
    Richard B, Wim, et. al. -- does the problem sound familiar?
    I'm going back on Tuesday with less time constraint, and hopefully your advice.
    TIA,
    Patrick Draine
    Billerica, MA
    


  • 2.  Petrov 125 IV noise problems

    Posted 10-29-2000 05:54
    From "Tom Driscoll" <tomtuner@mediaone.net>
    
    Pat,  This may not be your noise, But I had a noise resembling your
    description on a Walter console. Corrected by replacing bushings in the
    damper rod holders. They were hard as if soaked with glue but not glued in .
    In this piano during play as you describe the damper levers were bumping
    against the engaged rod when the key was released . The spoons were lifting
    the dampers slightly further than the pedal . Timing was correct so I didn't
    change them, but noticed that the noise went away if I pulled the dampers
    way off the strings by lifting up on the rod with my hand - This sent me to
    the swings and the bushings. Perhaps Alum. rail  a factor but I don't think
    so.Tom Driscoll


  • 3.  Petrov 125 IV noise problems

    Posted 10-29-2000 06:59
    From bases-loaded@juno.com
    
    Patrick -
    
    I had one just this week with similar symptoms, although it was not a
    Petrov.  Turned out to be the action post at the opposite end from the
    damper lifter lever rattling on it's support.  Tweaked the support up a
    tad and the noise was gone.  
    
    Hope you get that lucky...
    
    Mark Potter
    bases-loaded@juno.com
    
    On Sun, 29 Oct 2000 08:01:28 -0400 J Patrick Draine <draine@mediaone.net>
    writes:
    > Dear Petrov experts:
    > I have a customer with a new (3 months old) Petrov 125 IV, their 49" 
    > 
    > upright. I tuned it in June, shortly after delivery. He called 
    > yesterday complaining about annoying rattly action noise. My 
    > diagnosis based on the phone call was loose hammer flange screws, or 
    > 
    > even perhaps loose glue joints between the hammer/shank/butt -- but 
    > that was incorrect.
    > 
    > I dropped by late in the day with just a few minutes to spare before 
    > 
    > heading home in time for various family activities.
    > The noises are apparent mainly when the damper pedal is engaged and 
    > the piano is being played fairly vigorously. While we can isolate a 
    > few target source notes they don't generate much noise unless all 
    > the 
    > rest of the repetitive r&r/Bruce Hornsby/stride piano chording is 
    > going on at the same time.
    > If it were a grand I'd suspect damper wires vibrating slightly 
    > against bass strings -- but it's an upright.
    > I *did* tighten the hammer flanges, damper heads, damper flanges of 
    > the (suspected) source notes, but they were already firm, and no 
    > improvement occurred.
    > The pedal dowels were the next suspects: the plastic/metal 
    > pins/rubber contacts between the (aluminum not wood) dowels had 
    > excess free play  -- BUT installing a better bushing didn't help.
    > Is there something potentially funky about the damper lift rod 
    > bushings? I didn't have time to pull the action, but still managed 
    > to 
    > get home late & have the family ticked off at me.
    > The customer bought the piano in NYC to save $2K compared to the 
    > local dealer; the local dealer won't give him the time of day now, 
    > so 
    > dropping the problem on the local dealer isn't an option.
    > Besides, it *should* be the sort of thing that goes away with a few 
    > tightened screws, etc.!
    > Richard B, Wim, et. al. -- does the problem sound familiar?
    > I'm going back on Tuesday with less time constraint, and hopefully 
    > your advice.
    > TIA,
    > Patrick Draine
    > Billerica, MA
    


  • 4.  Petrov 125 IV noise problems

    Posted 10-29-2000 07:02
    From Richard Brekne <Richard.Brekne@grieg.uib.no>
    
    Sounds familiar alright... and it can be a difficult thing to track down. A few
    hints that might be of help, tho your discription of the noise could point to just
    about anything really.
    
    Check the bridge notching to make sure that strings have plenty clearance moveing
    off the bridge from any and all possible contact with the bridge.. especially along
    the side of the right string.
    
    Also check to see if there is any chips of wood laying jamed around in the string
    area. As far as the dampers go... the usual stuff applies.. make sure the system is
    regulated correctly with the pedal pulling the dampers out just a tad more then the
    depression of a key will, and make sure the stop rail is screwed tightly in place
    and that its not to far in. Also check the screws that hold the letoff button rail
    in place, and that this hasnt moved around any. Also check the damper lift rod
    hinges.. probably not the problem but its worth a check.
    
    >From the sounds of things something is contacting the strings when they are allowed
    to really vibrate at full amplitude. I even saw a Petrof come in once that had the
    damper system regulated such that the lower end of the damper lever was so close to
    the strings that many of them would actually contact the strings when the key was
    depressed... lovely regulation stuff..
    
    Good luck and drop another line when you have solved it, or need some more thought
    bouncing.
    
    Grin... Wim of course doesnt have to deal with these Petrofs... for some strange
    reason all of the Petrofs that come into his store are in perfect condition and are
    almost as good as the best of European pianos for a quarter of the price...
    
    sorry Wim... couldnt help myself... all in fun... besides... I know why you like
    them.. they do have a pretty nice overall sound.
    
    J Patrick Draine wrote:
    
    > Dear Petrov experts:
    > I have a customer with a new (3 months old) Petrov 125 IV, their 49"
    > upright. I tuned it in June, shortly after delivery. He called
    > yesterday complaining about annoying rattly action noise. My
    > diagnosis based on the phone call was loose hammer flange screws, or
    > even perhaps loose glue joints between the hammer/shank/butt -- but
    > that was incorrect.
    >
    > I dropped by late in the day with just a few minutes to spare before
    > heading home in time for various family activities.
    > The noises are apparent mainly when the damper pedal is engaged and
    > the piano is being played fairly vigorously. While we can isolate a
    > few target source notes they don't generate much noise unless all the
    > rest of the repetitive r&r/Bruce Hornsby/stride piano chording is
    > going on at the same time.
    > If it were a grand I'd suspect damper wires vibrating slightly
    > against bass strings -- but it's an upright.
    > I *did* tighten the hammer flanges, damper heads, damper flanges of
    > the (suspected) source notes, but they were already firm, and no
    > improvement occurred.
    > The pedal dowels were the next suspects: the plastic/metal
    > pins/rubber contacts between the (aluminum not wood) dowels had
    > excess free play  -- BUT installing a better bushing didn't help.
    > Is there something potentially funky about the damper lift rod
    > bushings? I didn't have time to pull the action, but still managed to
    > get home late & have the family ticked off at me.
    > The customer bought the piano in NYC to save $2K compared to the
    > local dealer; the local dealer won't give him the time of day now, so
    > dropping the problem on the local dealer isn't an option.
    > Besides, it *should* be the sort of thing that goes away with a few
    > tightened screws, etc.!
    > Richard B, Wim, et. al. -- does the problem sound familiar?
    > I'm going back on Tuesday with less time constraint, and hopefully your advice.
    > TIA,
    > Patrick Draine
    > Billerica, MA
    
    --
    Richard Brekne
    RPT, N.P.T.F.
    Bergen, Norway
    


  • 5.  Petrov 125 IV noise problems

    Posted 10-29-2000 07:11
    From "Joe & Penny Goss" <imatunr@primenet.com>
    
    Patrick,
    Key stick too long touching bass strings?
    Joe
    


  • 6.  Petrov 125 IV noise problems

    Posted 10-29-2000 07:43
    From Wimblees@AOL.COM
    
    In a message dated 10/29/00 6:17:53 AM Central Standard Time, 
    draine@mediaone.net writes:
    
    << The customer bought the piano in NYC to save $2K compared to the 
     local dealer; the local dealer won't give him the time of day now, so 
     dropping the problem on the local dealer isn't an option.
     Besides, it *should* be the sort of thing that goes away with a few 
     tightened screws, etc.!
     Richard B, Wim, et. al. -- does the problem sound familiar?
     I'm going back on Tuesday with less time constraint, and hopefully your 
    advice.
     TIA,
     Patrick Draine
     Billerica, MA >>
    
    
    Sorry, Pat, but I can't imagine what the problem would be. I have never heard 
    it. I am at home this morning (Sunday), but take a look Monday to see if I 
    can possibly identify a potential problem. 
    
    As far as the dealer situation is concerned. I guess this should be good 
    advertising for people to use local dealers, instead of "saving" money by 
    going to the big city. 
    
    Wim
    


  • 7.  Petrov 125 IV noise problems

    Posted 10-29-2000 07:54
    From Wimblees@AOL.COM
    
    In a message dated 10/29/00 8:28:12 AM Central Standard Time, 
    Richard.Brekne@grieg.uib.no writes:
    
    << From the sounds of things something is contacting the strings when they 
    are allowed
     to really vibrate at full amplitude. I even saw a Petrof come in once that 
    had the
     damper system regulated such that the lower end of the damper lever was so 
    close to
     the strings that many of them would actually contact the strings when the 
    key was
     depressed... lovely regulation stuff.
    
    After reading this post, this is what I am suspecting might be the problem. 
    How do you solve it?  I would think reducing the swing of the damper rod, 
    and/or actually shaving off some of the damper level wood. Before doing 
    anything drastic, however, I think you should call Alan Vincent at Geneva 
    International 800-533-2388, to explain the problem, and get permission to do 
    any work. . 
    .
    (snip)
     
     Grin... Wim of course doesnt have to deal with these Petrofs... for some 
    strange
     reason all of the Petrofs that come into his store are in perfect condition 
    and are
     almost as good as the best of European pianos for a quarter of the price...
     
     sorry Wim... couldnt help myself... all in fun... besides... I know why you 
    like
     them.. they do have a pretty nice overall sound.
    
    I know it is in good fun. Actually, I have had some Petrof's come in that 
    have needed some work. But all in all, I have been very happy with the 
    products I am getting. Now, as far as a quarter of the orice is concenred. I 
    wish that was true. :):)
    
    Wim
    


  • 8.  Petrov 125 IV noise problems

    Posted 10-30-2000 00:58
    From Richard Brekne <Richard.Brekne@grieg.uib.no>
    
    Wimblees@AOL.COM wrote:
    
    > In a message dated 10/29/00 8:28:12 AM Central Standard Time,
    > Richard.Brekne@grieg.uib.no writes:
    >
    > << From the sounds of things something is contacting the strings when they
    > are allowed  to really vibrate at full amplitude. I even saw a Petrof come in
    > once that
    > had the  damper system regulated such that the lower end of the damper lever
    > was so
    > close to  the strings that many of them would actually contact the strings
    > when the
    > key was depressed... lovely regulation stuff.
    >
    > After reading this post, this is what I am suspecting might be the problem.
    > How do you solve it?  I would think reducing the swing of the damper rod,
    > and/or actually shaving off some of the damper level wood. Before doing
    > anything drastic, however, I think you should call Alan Vincent at Geneva
    > International 800-533-2388, to explain the problem, and get permission to do
    > any work. .
    
    What I did was to completely regulate the dampers. Had to bend all the damper
    wires out a bit so that I had a rough regulation (very rough) that had the
    bottom part of the lever in a more reasonable distance from the string. Then it
    was bending the  spoons in rough so they were out of the way for basic pedal
    lift adjustment. Evened out the pedal adjustment, adjusted the pedal itself  and
    then regulated the spoons.
    
    A bit time consuming, and shoulda been unnecessary, but hey... thats why they
    pay us the big bucks... grin.
    
    >
    > Wim
    
    --
    Richard Brekne
    RPT, N.P.T.F.
    Bergen, Norway
    


  • 9.  Petrov 125 IV noise problems

    Posted 10-30-2000 05:48
    From J Patrick Draine <draine@mediaone.net>
    
    Thanks to all for their helpful replies. I was already considering 
    most of the various diagnoses, except for Richard's warning about 
    checking the bridge notching.
    As it turns out the customer called the NYC dealer about it after I 
    was there, and this time the dealer fumed that *no one* other than 
    their own designees are authorized to even diagnose (let alone fix) 
    the problem!
    Hopefully this means that they're going to do something about it; 
    meanwhile it's not my headache anymore!
    
    Patrick Draine