Hi, as an alternate option if you want to ship it to my shop we would very likely have a direct match we can send you back. We can remove the keytop and splice onto the donor key. Will likely be an undectable fix, as it would be similar aged donor key from a Baldwin. We wouldn't mind doing this one for fun for you. We've had a good deal of practice with this situation. Baldwin used CNC For a lot their key actions from that era, and always interesting how often we've been able to directly swap exact keys from similar model spinets.
------------------------------
Matthew Walworth
A.M.O. Pianos
Lebanon, TN 37087
------------------------------