Well, after looking at every angle here, I decided to send the casters back. Yamaha didn't charge any fees. Just had to pay return shipping.
I was just about to go ahead and cut the legs down, which seemed very doable with Rick's method, but decided the truck it's on could be fixed and save the money for other priorities.
Turns out a local welding shop can fix some slight bends and spot weld a couple spots to beef it up for about $150. We also made some slight adjustments to even out the truck and tighten everything up really snug as Jessica suggested. It did help a little as well.
It's certainly not as elegant as the casters but will be fine for now as it is our secondary piano in this location. I might be able to repaint it as well.
Glad to know all I know now if I run into similar issues in the future. Thanks so much for all the great feedback!
Jon
Original Message:
Sent: 9/19/2025 11:29:00 PM
From: David Graham
Subject: RE: Casters on a Yamaha CFX
A couple of data points on the CFIIIS at NIU, from 2008: double casters are 3 1/2", wood of leg is 20 1/2" ( bass and treble legs, didn't measure the nose leg). You likely have a CFIII, but would guess the measurements are similar.
I like the ASU protocol, but I don't have a great table saw, so, compound miter saw works for me. I don't think fear of what could go wrong is a reason to not do something, rather it is a reason to be careful. Fortunately pianos have three legs rather than four and they aren't cut on an angle like chair legs, so it really isn't too bad. If you have a less expensive piano to try it out first, that would be a confidence booster. Maybe an older piano that also sits too high on a stage truck, which is why I have done it.
On the other hand, if you can find proper legs or slightly smaller casters, great. We bought new legs for a donated D when we switched to the brass double casters. Since this is a donation, talk to the people in school foundation about needing to pay for this- it isn't that great an expense, and they want the donor to be happy with the result. In their minds,It would be like paying for a new bench for the piano, or some touch up work, which might get someone else to make a similar donation. Your director will be thinking about the current budget, they will be thinking long term strategy.
All of this assumes there is no threshold for the piano to clear. Otherwise, use a stage truck, beefed up if necessary to reduce bowing, or we use a Grand Piano Transporter to move the Fazioli 278 on and off stage, which weighs way more than the Yamaha, I had to have it modified by a local machinist to bow less. It still will bow some, but it works, with the same type of hydraulic jacks as a jack in the box. We just leave it under load long enough to get on and off stage, and then release the pressure. That works too. We never let the piano get all the way to the edge of the stage, so do not need a lip, but that depends on the size of your stage. If a leg did go over, the lyre would drop down and stop it, but I never want to see that theory tested. The only time a piano did go over the edge, it was on a stage truck, and while we couldn't prove it, it was probably deliberate. Piano flipped onto its lid, broke the prop stick. That was it, after falling four feet. Must have been very loud. Hope everyone is off to a great start of their semester.
David Graham
Graham Piano Service, Inc.
512 S. Main St.
Sycamore IL 60178
815-353-5450
Original Message:
Sent: 9/18/2025 12:37:00 AM
From: Jon Anderson
Subject: RE: Casters on a Yamaha CFX
Thanks James. I'm leaning towards finding a better piano truck solution. I too am hesitant to cut the legs down. Sounds possible but a bit scary. Just looking at all possible solutions.
I am still trying to get a hold of Yamaha. Will try again tomorrow. I do have access to a couple very heavy duty "carts" that I can rest it on if I take off the legs one at a time. A local refinisher had them made for this kinda job. I would still keep the jack in the box in place as well so I feel pretty comfortable with that.
I think it may come down to either buying new shorter legs, if they would even fit this older model, or looking into a better truck. A new truck will probably cost the same as the casters, but new legs will add onto the overall price significantly. We'll see what the people with the purse strings have to say. :)
After checking today, the truck it's on now appears to be adjusted correctly but it's pretty old and ugly, and obviously sagging. I've heard Jansen might be able to make a beefed up version for heavier pianos like this. I'll reach out to them as well to see.
Again, thanks everyone for all your thoughts and suggestions.
Original Message:
Sent: 9/17/2025 7:12:00 PM
From: James Kelly
Subject: RE: Casters on a Yamaha CFX
Before doing any cuts talk to the tech support people at Yamaha or you will be sorry, Cutting off material from the legs is not a great idea . If you ever tried to make cuts on chair legs or stools you will know what I mean. Anyway I had to put new casters on a Yamaha G2 due to some dogs using the legs as trees as well as the lyre and pedal box. I used a motorcycle scissor jack under the keybed as well as an hydraulic racing jack with pressure treated 4 x 4 posts plus some jack stands I do not trust the jack in the box due to seal failure potential and hydraulic fluid leaks . The new caster stems did not fit into the legs because they are current production. Had to use a small router and a pattern to take out wood and allow the tapered housing to seat properly. Fortunately Yamaha found a replacement lyre with the exact same finish and height. There was a metal beam under the keybed so the lyre was considered a short lyre . If the new casters raise the lyre you will want to fabricate a spacer to sit on top of the lyre between it and the keybed. I had to do this on 2 suzuki grand pianos purchased from Costco The pedal height was made for Asian pianists because of their shorter frame
------------------------------
James Kelly
Owner- Fur Elise Piano Service
Pawleys Island SC
(843) 325-4357
------------------------------
Original Message:
Sent: 09-17-2025 18:24
From: Jon Anderson
Subject: Casters on a Yamaha CFX
Yes the lyre would go down at first but the casters are 1 1/2" taller than the normal casters. It should all work out if I decide to cut off 1 1/2" from the legs which will make up the difference. If I just put these larger casters on the current legs, the lyre will be lifted up 1 1/2", for a total of at least 2" off the floor. Hope that makes sense.
Always good for me to rethink these things!
Original Message:
Sent: 9/17/2025 5:08:00 PM
From: Alan Eder
Subject: RE: Casters on a Yamaha CFX
if the purpose of shortening the legs is to compensate for the greater diameter of the replacement casters, in order to keep the keyboard at the same height above the floor, then it could be that the lyre will wind up the same distance from the floor as it was with the previous casters on the original legs.
------------------------------
Alan Eder, RPT
Herb Alpert School of Music
California Institute of the Arts
Valencia, CA
661.904.6483
------------------------------