You're not hijacking my thread. You're staying on subject and providing interesting and useful information. I'm grateful that my post garnered such interest. (BTW, you hinted that your previous post had pictures but... um... where are they?) Now, if your posts somehow changed the topic to something else, that might possibly be hijacking but it would really be an indication of someone not knowing how list servers and forums actually work.
Original Message:
Sent: 03-16-2025 17:06
From: Maggie Jusiel
Subject: String splicing question
Allan - Hope I'm not hijacking Geoff's thread. He may be interested in these pictures. One is a few knots where I made the loop on the new string segment large enough to go over the winding. You can tell which one I didn't bend inward far enough because it caught the winding. Boy was I annoyed with myself for that one. The other picture is of your knot and one of mine, which I would have called a standard knot. They are different in that my tails are against each other on the inside while yours are going through the outer part of the loops. I'm definitely going to be trying that one. I already like it better. ;-)
Tim sez: Le plaisir sera le notre. Peut être à Des Moines bien que nous avons toujours voulu venir au Canada.
------------------------------
Maggie Jusiel, RPT
Athens, WV
(304)952-8615
mags@timandmaggie.net
Original Message:
Sent: 03-16-2025 09:26
From: Allan Sutton
Subject: String splicing question
Maggie,
I'm glad you like my knot! It's actually a traditional knot, just threaded differently. I still need to determine the right proportions between the wire thickness, the loop diameter, and the tail length.
The challenge with larger winding is exactly why I started using this method-it keeps things more compact and secure. I'd love to see your pictures, even if they're just the end results!
...and... Bonjour Tim, au plaisir de se rencontrer un jour....au Canada ...��
Original Message:
Sent: 3/15/2025 10:43:00 PM
From: Maggie Jusiel
Subject: RE: String splicing question
Hi Geoff et al!
Sorry I didn't see this sooner. Glad you found my video useful! Yes, the hybrid knot is in there, but I just fell in love with Allan Sutton's knot. I expect I'll be using that in the future! I was going to share that I have done a traditional knot with a small amount of wire left near a winding by making the loop on the new piece of wire large enough to pass over the coil. This can work quite well when the coil isn't too think. I have pictures, but only of the end results. I expected I'd be trying this eventually on a thick coil, but I'm thinking Allan's knot would be better because it would avoid the extra large loop.
Daniel - Those are fantastic photos!
Allan - When I started playing your video, Tim (hubby) was in the room and started translating for me automatically. Haha! ;-)
Maggie
------------------------------
Maggie Jusiel, RPT
Athens, WV
(304)952-8615
mags@timandmaggie.net
Original Message:
Sent: 03-15-2025 15:08
From: Geoff Sykes
Subject: String splicing question
Daniel --
When I first saw your original post I just glanced at it as a description of how I already splice wires. But after reading Ron Koval's response I looked at it more closely. I agree, the use of the dummy wire for making the loop is a great idea that I had never heard of before. My only addition to the instructions you have provided would be to select the next thicker gauge wire for the splice wire. I was taught this as a way to reduce the possibility of the splice wire stretching and causing some minor instability after bringing the wire back up to tension. You are correct that your response did not address the question I had posted but it was, nevertheless, a valuable addition on the subject of wire splicing. Thanks --
------------------------------
Geoff Sykes, RPT
Los Angeles CA
Original Message:
Sent: 03-14-2025 09:48
From: Daniel DeBiasio
Subject: String splicing question
Geoff,
I read your original post again and realized that the tutorial I posted was not what you were asking for.
I think you might be thinking of the January 2019 issue of the Piano Technician's Journal.
Also, Maggie Jusiel has an excellent video on YouTube about this topic called "Three Piano Wire Knots"
------------------------------
Daniel DeBiasio
Technical Education & Support
ddebiasio@steinway.com
718-267-3229
Steinway & Sons
Original Message:
Sent: 03-13-2025 18:46
From: Geoff Sykes
Subject: String splicing question
We all know, or should know, how to tie a tuners knot to splice a broken string. Also, that this splice/knot, at least in plain wire strings, must be made in a non-speaking part of the string. With wound bass strings, it's frequently possible to put that splice/knot in the speaking length when the break is at the agraffe. Many times it will work just fine. But, making that splice in the speaking length of a wound bass string near the agraffe can usually present us with a core wire length that is too short to make that splice/knot in the conventional manner. As I was wrestling with this exact situation today I remembered that I once read, or saw a video, of a way to make a splice like this without having to make the loop in the added on splice wire first, slipping it over the bass string and then making the loop on the bass string in order to slip the first piece back through. In other words, as I remember it, this was a method that allowed for making the bass string loop first and then adding the added on splice wire to that splice/knot afterwards, with the results being a traditional tuners knot. Did I dream this, or does such a method exist? And if it does, can someone point me to the instructions on how to accomplish it?
Thanks --
------------------------------
Geoff Sykes, RPT
Los Angeles CA
------------------------------