I have, in the last couple of years done a bunch of Steinway action
frame rebuilds, so I got to talk to numbers of techs regarding their
empirical experience regarding choice of rail felts or emery cloth, or
nothing.
Of course there is no consensus, but there does seem to be a series of
trad-offs one can choose to accept.
-self-stick thin felt S&S used to supply...I say used to because I'm
pretty sure their current go to is string braid...so I'm not sure they
are supplying this any more. Tradeoffs...relative mushy placement of
action centers vs good shank mating to string memory. Some reported,
that seasonally, when flanges loosened up a bit, the felts memory guided
the flange back to the original position.
-fine emery or light backing 220 silicon carbide...less mushy center
placement. Memory ok if a little dab of shellac is used, otherwise, with
no shellac some movement
-nothing...most precise center placement, easier all around, IMO
requires a little dab of shallac at the rail
-string braid...has its adherents, and is S&S's current opinion (for the
next 5 minutes at least). Personally I don't get it, and I have not
heard arguments for this...would like to hear some perspectives on this.
-ditch the bloody frames completely, and go with new WNG stacks...my
personal choice, at this point.
Original Message------
Using felt seems counter productive. Try fine emory cloth and double-sided tape (3M makes 1/2" strips for window shrink plastic.
------------------------------
Regards,
Jon Page