Sax is pretty far from being "fixed pitch." Any sax player can and will bend pitch within a much wider range than most other wind instruments.
That said, "melody instruments" (instruments that play one note) are constantly bending pitch to meet various aims.
For example, they might bend a note sharp as a leading tone, or they might bend a note flat as a "blue note" to meet expressive melodic goals.
In ensemble, they will bend pitch to blend harmonically with the other instruments.
Only fixed pitch instruments play in fixed temperaments. Fixed temperaments are all compromises, trying to meet the needs of the music is a "least bad" way.
For the piano in particular, an equal temperament that is based on maximizing the alignment of partials throughout the range will lead to a coherence of sound, reinforcement of every note when the dampers are raised. This is what pure twelfth or pure 19th tuning is aiming at, and is what PianoMeter and PianoScope do - and I guess that OnlyPure is aiming at that, but its methodology is too obscure to make any real assessment. How a piano is tuned is important for its voice as an instrument.
For non-fixed pitch instruments, it can be a problem to align with the piano or any fixed pitch instrument, but that is the nature of the problem of tuning. The best tuning for an ensemble is one that is created on the fly, from note to note, from chord to chord: the pitches aren't fixed, they adapt.
------------------------------
Fred Sturm
University of New Mexico
fssturm@gmail.comhttp://fredsturm.nethttp://www.artoftuning.com"We either make ourselves happy or miserable. The amount of work is the same." - Carlos Casteneda
------------------------------
Original Message:
Sent: 06-08-2026 01:12
From: Blaine Hebert
Subject: How does a fixed pitch instrument such as Sax cope with unequal tuning?
One of my influential memories was in my senior year of high school. I am from a family of piano tuners and musicians and my high school senior year was spent at a magnet school where I was majoring in music. In a music lab I heard a recorded performance of a university saxophone choir that played in perfect tune. I had never heard perfect tuning before and the sound of 7 musicians playing without equal temperament was life changing. I love to hear chamber music and a cappella choirs and often recommend that customers try listening to well trained choirs and chamber music on YouTube. Our finest tunings are actually poor in comparison.
------------------------------
Blaine Hebert RPT
Duarte CA
(626) 390-0512
------------------------------