Wim - that's good news, although I've heard, possibly here that even in the US there are too many music schools turning out graduates for whom there isn't enough work. However, I'm not in the US and not qualified to comment so please take that observation with a pinch of salt.
Certainly in the UK the situation is dire. State schools haven't taught piano in decades. Drums and guitars are favoured, at best, and it's only private schools where children have access to pianos and the government has just imposed Value Added Tax at 20% or so on fees so causing many children to be pulled out of private schools and the schools are closing. They've been closing for some time and one, a casualty of Covid particularly
https://www.latrobeheritage.org.uk/save-ashdown has more than a passing interest for more than American musicians. Music and the arts in England have near collapsed.
If the USA is apparently better, please don't rely on it. The forces upon our civilisations are the same. If it hasn't happened yet or now, it will do in the future.
In France the situation is rather better. Regional orchestras are nationally state sponsored and the number of concerts and music festivals is healthy. In Greece, however, musicians are good but Conservatoires have had budget cuts and not been able to pay their way. It's all very patchy. And then there's the more corrosive factor that modern electronic music is more exciting with flashing lights, even to the middle aged
https://clubdefromage.com/.
Because current studentship is generations away from those who Beethoven, Bach or Chopin taught, nuances have become diluted. Seymour Bernstein is one of my heros
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pRLBBJLX-dQ and a pianist for whom I tune is in his mould as well also as that of Paul Badura-Skoda. But competition judges are choosing the false god of "accuracy" and "technique" over that of musical emotional communication and in worship of a Goddess called Angela who plays an Italian brand of instrument who plays Mendelssohn as if Prokofiev - and clearly hasn't sung a note in her life - and plays the Appassionata without passion, doesn't know what it is. Meanwhile in the recent Florida Chopin competition there was a technically admirable woman who played Mazurkas clearly without having been to Poland to dance one, and therefore with the wrong rhythm. I love the "English spoken as Chinese" series videos
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/QnRCcoNVMA8 which really highlight
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/Mpkdz6Zr9oc how emotional communication of music has become equally unintelligible.
Music has pitch, tempo, dynamics . . . but more. It has keys - and with restoration of the tuning which was inherent to pianos whilst the instrument and its repertoire were developing, those keys unlock doors to different rooms - different sounds, moods - and surprises. To the musical performer, the modulations are the cornerstones and landmarks in the narrative through which the music is leading. But the keys have been erased with high speed trains traversing the valleys and boring through the tunnels of hills without regard for the landscape.
We're aware that the likes of Facebook turns the perspective of product on its head. In the illusion that it is the product and we are the users, we wake up to find that we are the product. In the same way, the Brand pianos in the 1880s with cross stringing appeared to be the product. But the increasingly equal temperament grating with the ET thirds caused the whole instrument to glisten in sound and we were to become bedazzled. The players and the audiences became the product and the playing adapted progressively accordingly. The Competitions and their judges became the product of the manufacturers, not of the music. The junk noise of the dazzling glistening sound caused so much confusion players ceased to use sustain to sustain, and hardly dared leave the sustain pedal down beyond the end of each note.
There's something about the development of piano tone juggling 3rd and 5th harmonics which occured in the 19th century but that's another story. By moving away from the current tuning back to the tunings based on historic principles, we can start to return to the players the aural cues for any good musician who listens to follow. In doing so the music will convey, and become an essential deep experience with which other pastimes, let alone sport or the nightclub, cannot compete.
Yes we can achieve Yoga in the sound of the piano in the home keys and those keys, being the keys with which beginners start, can make a beautiful sound with which people can and do fall in love. When we reduce the glistening of the sound, the noise of beat frequencies everywhere all over the place, and put the beats upon particular notes and which composers exploited, we can get those notes to sing. Singing is the heart of music.
The piano can do it, and when it does prosperity, of the industry and of the hearts of the listeners, will thrive.
Best wishes
David P
-- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
David Pinnegar, B.Sc., A.R.C.S.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
+44 1342 850594
Original Message:
Sent: 2/2/2025 5:57:00 PM
From: Wim Blees
Subject: RE: Piano industry heading off a cliff
David
I don't know how it is in the UK, but here in the States, most college music departments are at full capacity. Those kids have to be learning music somewhere before they get to college. I agree that many schools cut back on music education, but there are still lots of schools that have great music departments, offering a full curriculum of band, orchestra, chorus and music education.
Wim
Original Message:
Sent: 2/2/2025 5:39:00 PM
From: David Pinnegar
Subject: RE: Piano industry heading off a cliff
With due respect to all, it's not the hardware that's the problem but one that's more serious - the software.
The software is the education, the people who play and why they play, and the essential necessity or not of playing.
Whilst the industry worships autistic players who worship the dots on the page but don't understand emotion to convey, the result will be only optional sport. Speed, technique, animal excitement. The nightclub does that better.
With the piano we have to go back to basics, to why we are making or maintaining the hardware, and rejigging it to enable better nuances of the software it can support.
Here's a young lad for whom I tuned last year
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kau_f51ZpXk . See his smile! We can put that smile on the faces of audiences and then they will be more keen to encourage their children to learn. Whoopee! Back in business.
Best wishes
David P
-- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
David Pinnegar, B.Sc., A.R.C.S.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
+44 1342 850594
Original Message:
Sent: 2/2/2025 3:13:00 PM
From: Paul McCloud
Subject: RE: Piano industry heading off a cliff
Yes, though I'm not sure the current situation. When I worked at the store, we sold George Steck, manufactured by Sejung. I think they also made the Falcone after the original company went out. It's hard to keep up! Before our store went out, we had Nordiska. They eventually sold the factory to Baldwin, but they aren't Nordiskas. I'm not sure that Nordiskas are made anymore. Who knows, maybe somebody will resurrect that name too. It was originally a company from Netherlands I believe.
------------------------------
Paul McCloud, RPT
Accutone Piano Service
www.AccutonePianoService.com
pavadasa@gmail.com
------------------------------
Original Message:
Sent: 02-02-2025 15:02
From: Alan Eder
Subject: Piano industry heading off a cliff
Paul,
Do you know that the Falcone name was bought by the concern in China that now makes pianos under that name?
Alan
------------------------------
Alan Eder, RPT
Herb Alpert School of Music
California Institute of the Arts
Valencia, CA
661.904.6483
Original Message:
Sent: 02-02-2025 14:21
From: Paul McCloud
Subject: Piano industry heading off a cliff
I entered the piano industry in 1988, as an apprentice in a large piano store. We had Steinway, Baldwin, Kawai and Samick. We were selling pianos like hotcakes. At least a Steinway a month, two or three Baldwins a week, same with Kawai. A couple Samicks a day, all different models. There were 3 apprentices, our mentor and another experienced tech. We couldn't keep up with the tunings. They'd go out in a box, delivered unprepped. After the Gulf War, the whole atmosphere changed. There was a recession. Steinway came out with the Boston, to compete with the KG series. We couldn't sell enough of either one, so they both went to other stores. Since that time, as on a sinking ship, the water gradually came over the gunnels over the following years. Eventually we went out, at least two changes of ownership in between. In my opinion, since the introduction of cheap Korean and Chinese pianos, the American brands have declined. Baldwin had to go to China after Gibson tried hard to keep it going in the US, and finally gave up. I can only imagine that the whole piano manufacturing sector in the US and Europe has taken a hit from all the cheap pianos coming from Asia. Add to that the economic conditions, the Internet booms, real estate crashes, bubbles, bailouts, rate cuts, etc., that have muddied the waters. Piano sales are like the coal mine canary. Pianos are not a necessity, but a luxury item. So when the economy is weak, piano sales go down too. And never mind the rebuilding shops that have gone out because it's cheaper to buy a new Asian piano than to rebuild Grandma's piano. Those shops are where many newbies learned the trade. The store where I worked shed nearly all the full time techs, and my job went away too, except we made an agreement that any outside work I did through the store we would profit-share. But even that didn't work out, and the store ended in a fire sale. With Yamaha's part ownership of Bosendorfer and other arrangements, it's just a sign of the times. Somebody's going to buy the Grotrian name and make them in China, just like the Falconi and other brands that are made there (Baldwin). The tariffs that are coming are too little too late, IMHO, but whatever. Don't want to bring up politics. If these companies are dwindling or going out, there's still enough demand for somebody to make them, even if theyr'e all made in Asia. I don't think it's the end of piano manufacturing, just those makers whose sales are too low to continue. Just wait for Samick corp to start making Grotrians in Korea. Even if every piano maker went belly up, we'd still have enough work and more.
My .02 cents.
------------------------------
Paul McCloud, RPT
Accutone Piano Service
www.AccutonePianoService.com
pavadasa@gmail.com
Original Message:
Sent: 02-01-2025 10:23
From: David Pinnegar
Subject: Piano industry heading off a cliff
Dear Colleagues
It's with sadness and shock that I learned today of Grotrian closing its factory and a few weeks ago I heard that Steinway is not working a full 5 day week.
A headline in the UK papers publicised a performer setting up a concert to perform the same piece 820 times. This is not music - it's only sport.
Sport is optional.
Music as communication of emotion is essential. If it's essential and reaches the heart, then there will be reason for all to appreciate the teaching of it.
Now for nearly two decades I've been researching, discovering and refining and have an answer to musicians to be able to convey better emotion. Upon being asked by musicians if they can perform at Hammerwood, I'm blunt in telling them that I'm only interested in musicians who appreciate more than tempo, dynamics and pitch but also key as an equivalently important part of the music as tonality which the composers wrote into their work. The microtonalism of key has been thrown away by modern tuning and the piano manufacturers are suffering now the result.
Another Steinway Artist recently told me after I'd revoiced and tuned her Model M that she was now more in love with her instrument than ever since she bought it.
Here's a London friend trying his instrument after tuning to the strongest general purpose tuning that one might dare
Test of Steinway Model O piano in Kirnberger III unequal temperament
YouTube | remove preview |
| Test of Steinway Model O piano in Kirnberger III unequal temperament | Testing a Model O Steinway in unequal temperament using Kirnberger III | View this on YouTube > |
|
|
This manner of tuning requires a special technique to achieve which differs from the commonly accepted norms. I've given the clues to a few colleagues confidentially and in particular Tim Foster who is having much success.
I'm willing to work with any piano manufacturer willing to take on the tuning as a standard option and guarantee that if any instrument is tuned by Tim or I in a showroom, that instrument will be the one with which the best of musicians will fall in love inescapably.
For its own survival, the industry has to focus on music, on emotion rather than merely technique and resulting sport. Perhaps we can bring manufacturers back from the brink.
Best wishes
David P
------------------------------
David Pinnegar BSc ARCS
Hammerwood Park, East Grinstead, Sussex, UK
+44 1342 850594
"High Definition" Tuning
------------------------------